Reception
Mary Butts’
(1890-1937) was an English modernist novelist, short story writer
and reviewer, highly regarded in her lifetime. She published in
journals such as The Little Review and The Bookman and was admired
for her work by luminaries such as T.S. Eliot and Bryher, as well
as moving amongst the constellations of writers and patrons who
define the way we perceive literary modernism today. After her
death, the memory of her short stories and novels was eclipsed by
the perception of Butts as a socialite. A renewal of interest in
her work began in the 1980s with a conference and in the 1990s, the
republication of many of her novels and stories.
A brief overview of Mary
Butts' life and works
Mary Franeis Butts was born on December
13th, 1890, in Dorset, England, the daughter of Captain Frederick
John Butts. The Captain resided in the magnificent ancestral estate
of Salterns, in Parkstone, and his wife was Mary Jane Briggs,
granddaughter of a successful jute merchant. Growing up in Salterns
meant that Butts was surrounded by fine books and furniture, and
most notably William Blake paintings that had been in the family
since the time of Thomas Butts, her great-grandfather, and an
important patron of Blake. As a child she lived an isolated rural
life, one which taught her the value of loving nature, and in
nature, to “see power”1. Butts felt intimate above all with
her father, with whom she felt she shared a “secret
knowledge” and who raised her on “cycles of antique
story telling”2.
Butts’ father died when she was
fourteen, leaving her ancestral home in the possession of her
mother, who in Butts’ opinion “und[id] in less than
half a lifetime the work of centuries”3 by selling beloved family heirlooms to
cover his death-duties. Butts felt cheated of a cultural legacy
through which she felt she could connect to her father’s
spirit. In response to this her fiction frequently narrates the
spiritual re-connection of female outsiders to land which is
presented as their natural inheritance. For these reasons Butts has
been described as an "expatriate from an imaginary
England”4. Butts’ fiction tends to pit
psychological dissolution and the invasion of the countryside
against heroines who represent the possibility of spiritual
renewal. Characters such as Van Ashe in Ashe of Rings or Scylla in Armed With Madness are depicted as the true inheritors of
the countryside and its magic secrets. Through these secrets they
offer the hope of a renewal of spiritual and rural values which
Butts thought were under threat from the innovations of the modern
age. Towards the end of the 1920s Butts' thinking became
increasingly preoccupied by what she saw as threats to the
countryside. In 1928 she begun Death of Felicity Taverner, a novel which centres around the
conflict between an aristocratic English family and a Jewish
Russian who wishes to buy up their land in order to bring in
tourists. The novel exemplifies Butts racialised view of the world
(for more on this see Patterson's account of its
anti-Semitism5), but it is also her tribute to
detective fiction, offering a brilliant synthesis of her modernist
descriptions of land and seascapes with the plot-driven intrigue of
that genre. The novel was begun in France, where Butts had lived
amongst the international literary elite for most of the 1920s. But
1930 saw her moving to Sennen in the far west of Cornwall, a land
she saw as removed from the worst excesses of materialist
modernity. It was here that she came to reject the decadent
lifestyle she had lived in France, rediscovered Christianity, and
wrote her last work, the autobiography The Crystal Cabinet: My Childhood at
Salterns.
It was here that Butts died in 1937, as a result of her long term
problems with narcotics.
For a thorough account of Mary Butts' life, see Nathalie Blondel's
indispensable Mary Butts: Scenes from the Life.
1 Mary Butts,
The Crystal Cabinet: My Childhood At Salterns.
Boston: The
Beacon Press, 1998, p11.
2 Ibid, p17, p11.
3 Ibid, p13.
4 Ian Patterson, ‘‘The Plan Behind the Plan": Russians,
Jews and Mythologies of Change: The Case of Mary Butts", Bryan
Cheyette, Laura Marcus (eds.), Modernity, Culture and ‘the
Jew’, Cambridge: Polity Press, 1998, p127.
5
Ibid.